West Surrey Shadow Authority has backed costed budget amendments, a separate scrutiny officer and recorded committee votes at the request of a single member.

Any single member of a West Surrey Shadow Authority committee can now ask for a recorded vote, so residents in Farnham and across the new council’s area can see in the published minutes how each councillor on that committee voted.

The rule was one of three governance changes approved with immediate effect at the Shadow Authority meeting on Thursday 19 November at Millmead House, Guildford. The other two set out how next year’s budget will be debated and amended, and give scrutiny its own designated officer.

Overview

  • Recorded votes: one member can now request a recorded vote in any committee or sub-committee. Full Council still needs 10 members to ask.
  • Budget rules: every budget amendment must be lawful and costed by officers, with written reasons if statutory officers reject one.
  • Scrutiny: the Designated Scrutiny Officer is now the Scrutiny Officer rather than the Monitoring Officer.
  • When: all three took effect on 19 November. The budget is due to be set next February.

All three were recommended by the Standards Committee and moved by its chair, Cllr Richard Wilson, the Shadow Authority councillor for Bagshot, Windlesham and Chobham. The Shadow Authority runs from the elections in May 2026 until 1 April 2027, when West Surrey Council formally takes over services, including those Waverley Borough Council provides in Farnham now.

Recorded votes in committees

Most council votes are taken on a show of hands, and the minutes record only whether a motion was carried or lost. In a recorded vote each councillor’s name is called in turn, and whether they voted for, against or abstained is written into the published minutes.

Under the new rule, one member is enough to call for a recorded vote in any committee or sub-committee. In Full Council the threshold stays at 10 members.

Cllr Wilson said: “This improves transparency in committees while maintaining efficiency in the Shadow Authority.

“Any member of a committee can now ask for a recorded vote there. That will involve a maximum of 15 votes. It will increase the time required a bit, but it should not result in business being incomplete.”

On keeping the higher bar in Full Council, he said: “We are keeping the requirement for 10 councillors in Full Council because conducting a roll call of 90 councillors is time-consuming, difficult for the watching public to follow, and risks business being left incomplete. Recorded votes in Full Council should be called for sparingly.”

At the annual budget meeting the law requires a recorded vote on the budget and on every amendment, whatever the 10-member threshold.

A costed budget for February

The Shadow Authority added its own Budget Procedure Rules and a Budget Setting Protocol to its constitution. Under them, every amendment to the budget has to be lawful and properly costed by officers, and if statutory officers reject one they must give their reasons in writing. Each political group is to get a fair opportunity, and support, to put amendments forward, and all members can speak in a single combined debate on the budget and the amendments.

“This ensures we set a lawful budget next February,” Cllr Wilson said. “Members will have assurance that all amendments are lawful and costed properly by officers. Each political group will have a fair opportunity to submit amendments, and all members will have the opportunity to speak in the combined debate.”

A separate officer for scrutiny

The third change moves the role of Designated Scrutiny Officer from the Monitoring Officer to the Scrutiny Officer.

“This proposal enhances governance by separating the roles of Scrutiny Officer and Monitoring Officer,” Cllr Wilson said. “This is best practice and improves the transparency and independence of Scrutiny in the Shadow Authority.

“It means the officer advising Scrutiny is not the same officer advising the Leader and the Executive. That separation is what gives Scrutiny its independence.”

Summing up the three changes, he said: “Taken together, these items provide good governance for the Shadow Authority: a lawful budget, independent scrutiny, and transparent votes where it matters most.”

Source: Cllr Richard Wilson, Chair of the Standards Committee, West Surrey Shadow Authority.