Waverley councillors voted down a motion to review ethical procurement over Palestine by 14 to 9. Another 14 abstained, including Leader Paul Follows.

Waverley Borough Council has voted down a motion asking it to review its ethical procurement policy in the light of the war in Gaza. Nine councillors voted for it on Tuesday night, 14 voted against and 14 abstained.

The Mayor announced the result at Full Council on 10 November, after a debate of almost an hour. It is on the council’s webcast of the meeting, at about 2 hours 20 minutes. The written minutes have not been published yet.

The motion came from Green Party councillor Steve Williams, who represents Godalming Binscombe and Charterhouse. It was seconded by Daniel Husseini, an independent councillor for the same ward. We reported what it asked for when it was published.

What the council turned down

The four proposals were taken together. If passed, the council would have:

  • reaffirmed that its procurement and finances reflect its ethical commitments, including the risk of contributing to serious violations of international law
  • asked the Executive to review how its ethical procurement policy is applied in practice
  • asked the Leader to write to the Surrey Pension Fund and the incoming West Surrey Council on responsible investment
  • had the review reported back to Full Council and passed to West Surrey Council

None of it would have cancelled a contract or named a company (motion text).

Why the Leader abstained

Council Leader Paul Follows, a Liberal Democrat, told the meeting he believed Israel’s actions in Palestine were a genocide. He said he could not bring himself to vote against the motion “as a matter of conscience”.

But he said he could not vote for it either. His reasons:

  • the council’s procurement strategy already covers the points raised, and the motion gave no evidence of non-compliance
  • officers are working flat out to get the council “safe and legal” for vesting day, less than 20 weeks away
  • the Surrey pension arrangements will change at vesting day, so the letter would go to the wrong body

He said West Surrey Council’s own procurement would address the issue.

Finance portfolio holder Mark Merryweather, also a Liberal Democrat, said the council has no policy by the name the motion used. He said the review it asked for “identifies no shortcomings” and set no timeline.

The case against

Conservative group leader Jane Austin said the motion was “simply not the business of Waverley Borough Council”. She quoted local government minister Jim McMahon, who said on 4 November that foreign policy is a matter for national government. She voted against.

Conservative councillor Peter Martin, for Godalming Holloway, said he had not signed the Palestine Solidarity Campaign’s pledge. He said pension funds should focus on returns for their members. He also voted against.

George Murray, who leads the Farnham Residents and Aligned Independents group, said he questioned the timing rather than the motive. He said the review would fall on officers already stretched by reorganisation. He would not support it, but said his group were free to vote with their conscience.

The case for

Cllr Williams said his first proposal had gone further, to consider a boycott of Israeli products through procurement. He said that version had been ruled inadmissible under the council’s constitution. He called the motion “a practical step forward” and said Waverley should leave West Surrey “the right legacy”.

Cllr Husseini said he is half Lebanese and has relatives in south Lebanon who have fled their homes. He said the motion was “basic due diligence when spending public money”.

Haslemere East councillor Terry Weldon said he began campaigning against apartheid in Cape Town 56 years ago. He said he endorsed the motion’s sentiment but was concerned about its detail and the load on officers, and was minded to abstain.

What it means for you

Nothing changes in how the council buys goods and services. Its existing procurement strategy stands until Waverley is abolished on 1 April 2027.

From then, West Surrey Council will set its own procurement rules. Councillors on both sides of Tuesday’s debate said the question would be for the new authority.

Sources